This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.

Perspectives

| 2 minute read

Seventh Circuit Rejects Federal Officer Removal for Patient Portal Claims

Federal incentives and regulations do not make healthcare providers federal actors when they operate patient portals.

In Elkins v. Southeastern Indiana Health Management, Inc., issued October 20, 2026, the Seventh Circuit joined five sister circuits in holding that healthcare providers do not “act under” the federal government merely by operating patient portals encouraged by federal law. The portals may advance federal policy, but that is not enough to support removal under the federal officer removal statute. 

The plaintiffs alleged that Columbus Regional Health ("CRH") embedded Meta Pixel tracking software in its website and disclosed their health information without consent. They sued in Indiana state court for breach of implied contract, unjust enrichment, and violations of state consumer-protection and wiretapping laws. CRH removed the case under 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1), arguing that it acted under the Department of Health and Human Services when it created its patient portal. Four similar appeals were consolidated with the case.

The Seventh Circuit rejected that theory. A private party “acts under” the federal government when it helps perform a federal duty or task under federal guidance or control. Following federal law, even within a detailed regulatory system, is not enough.

The court contrasted patient portals with work performed by federal contractors. In Ruppel v. CBS Corp., for example, a manufacturer produced turbines for a naval aircraft carrier under detailed government specifications. That contractor helped the government perform work it otherwise would have done itself. Healthcare providers, by contrast, create portals for their own patients and staff. The portals may further federal policy, but they do not carry out a basic governmental task.

The HITECH Act did not change that conclusion. The Act encouraged providers to adopt electronic health records through incentive payments and later reduced Medicare reimbursements for providers that failed to meet program requirements. But responding to those incentives did not transform private patient portals into federal projects. As the court explained, a private party does not perform a governmental task every time it acts in response to a federal incentive. 

Nor did the federal government closely control how providers designed or maintained their portals. The regulations required providers to give patients electronic access to their health information but largely left the method to them. The providers also cited a federal Patient Engagement Playbook, but the court found that its nonbinding tips and best practices fell far short of the detailed specifications and continuing supervision needed for federal officer removal.

The decision aligns the Seventh Circuit with the Third, Fifth, Eighth, Ninth, and Tenth Circuits, all of which have rejected similar removal arguments. Those decisions draw a clear line: federal regulations may shape private conduct without making that conduct federal action.

Key Takeaways

  • Regulation is not delegation. Compliance with federal EHR requirements does not mean a provider is performing the federal government’s work.
  • Federal incentives are not enough. Advancing federal policy in response to payments or reimbursement reductions does not establish an “acting under” relationship.
  • Control remains critical. Federal officer removal generally requires detailed federal direction, monitoring, or supervision, not nonbinding guidance about how a private entity should operate.

For healthcare providers facing state law claims over website tracking technology, participation in federal EHR programs will not, by itself, necessarily open a path to federal court under § 1442(a)(1).

Tags

healthcare, illinois, appellate